Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

For more adversarial interactions
User avatar
Trebb
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2025 12:15 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Trebb »

Nessie wrote: Tue Dec 23, 2025 2:46 pm
....

https://www.uklfi.com/doctor-suspended- ... ic-conduct

"UKLFI provided photographic evidence of Dr Kriesels attending multiple pro-Palestinian demonstrations in London holding a hand-drawn placard depicting the Israeli flag alongside the words: “rape, steal, cry, kill, cheat, lie.”

This sign, aimed at Israelis as a whole, constitutes a sweeping racist generalisation and a clear example of antisemitism. She carried the placard at events on 4 June, 19 July, and 6 September 2025, and was also photographed giving an obscene gesture towards Jewish counter-demonstrators.

UKLFI had also documented some of Dr Kriesels’ extremist posts on X, where she repeatedly claimed that Jews—Zionist or not—embodied “supremacy,” described Judaism as “racist, imperialist and genocidal,” and stated she was “sickened” by Jews.

The UKLFI complaint highlighted that Dr Kriesels publicly characterised Hamas as “oppressed resistance fighters” and “not terrorists,” potentially breaching Section 12(1A) of the Terrorism Act 2000, which prohibits expressing support for a designated terrorist organisation."
So Kriesel's wrongdoings are

1) she accused Israel of raping, theft, crying(!), killing, cheating and lying.

2) claimed Jews were supremacist, racist, imperialist and genocidal.

3) that she called the Palestinian terrorists "oppressed freedom fighters".

And she was arrested for these, very commonplace observations/ opinions.

I am very surprised, or would be very surprised by this, if not for the obvious sissy politics we have had in the UK, since at least 2016. I am a Briton too, one who was vehemently opposed to our invasion of Iraq in 2003 because it was patently obvious that it was totally a war of aggression by the UK and the USA. What has alarmed me ever since is that our devious, warmongering Prime Minister suffered not the slightest consequence for it, and was never even voted out of office. Prime Ministers these days don't even make it to their first chance of re-election. Instead, they are replaced on the whims of the civil service and their allies abroad to suit various Globalist agendas.

The consequences of that war have been devastating to Europe, the UK and the Middle East, and the USA looks like it is fatally in debt because of it, but the outrage just died down. We bombed the Middle East and Afghanistan and imported the survivors - a course of action entirely in keeping with Blairism, whose government gave us your Terrorism Act 2000. But what was by far the biggest outrage of the century so far? The British people voted to leave the European Union and become like the majority of nations on Earth, non-members! Those that supported such a move have long suffered the boring litany or terms in your post, e.g., cheats, liars, even supremacists, racist (of course), and even genocidal, given that they were obviously also admonished as "literal Hitler". This shrill and artificial outrage has totally deranged political and civic life in the UK.

So it is not at all surprising that the Globalist Left can get so selectively touchy over anything related to identity politics. It is also tragic-hilarious that the deranged Labour Party does not really know what to do with itself, after its default victory in the latest General Election, veering from defending wonky Antifa, Jew-affectionate positions (e.g., attacking Corbyn's antisemitism) to placating its massive Muslim column.

So having imported and established a large Muslim presence, its simultaneous placation of the UK Zionist interests, the UK is now giving the World a jaw-dropping spectacle of improvised, on-the-fly tyranny. What and who will the UK government come to rely on to "manage" its divided population? It has no real armed forces, a camp and flabby Police Force that is ever more hated and all against a background of gargantuan, zombie statist structures like the chronically failing National Health Service behemoth, that is itself wholly dependent on the Ponzi Scheme of ever more immigration to staff it and ever more of their immigrant families to need it, whilst they fleece the Social benefits system.

What a pickle! Every one of the claims Kriesel made is reasonable, some require some context, some are just plain facts. All could be made toward either side in this wider Arab-Zionist rigmarole, to some extent. Even theft; not sure Jews should not feel cheated by paying a non-Muslim tax in the days before they won their state.

Interesting how the UK Police select their arrestees - the targets are those that suit best the Police's monumental cowardice. Middle class mothers and elderly women with osteoporotic spines are perfect! Beside the point...

It strikes me as very odd that Nessie, or anyone, would honestly think that Kriesel's comments are arrest-worthy.

On a wider view of the whole thread and its question, well, yes, it is legitimate for any collective action, i.e., on behalf of a group, to be eligible for moral assessment and, where found to be in the wrong, due criticism. Otherwise you get this weird Casper the Friendly Ghost Phenomenon:

Casper can shove a material vase off its stand by first moving his immaterial hand through the solid wall.

Jews are the collective that suffered material harm owing to National Socialism, but any negative effect of the collective actions they make to benefit themselves is immaterial.


I am a Christian, raised as a Roman Catholic in a very Jewish area, with many Jewish friends over the years. My mother's maternal line is Jewish just two wombs above her (I would be a shoo-in for a Jewish convert, though there is no family memory of any Jewish tradition-keeping or observance, and there is the whole coming of Jesus thing). I do sway on the whole Israel question. I am now still vaguely in support of the state's continuance, but I think it has become a peril to many nations, not least the USA, where a heavy dose of Logan Act would help. Talk about a troubling alliance!

So, the only recourse against this conclusion (Jews may well be accountable for collective actions, just like the evil Nazi Brexiteers are) is for Nessie and the dearly deported Confused Jew to say "not all Jews!". Well, yes, great, but it does not get you very far. It is entirely legitimate for nations to want to treat the Jewish state as an independent, foreign state and hence rid itself of things like AIPAC or mitigate the effects of the widespread sayanim. If one wanted to dress this up nicely, one could say, "It aint all Jews, we just reject the Isreali spy and influencer network" - not sure that would keep the UK Police away from elderly female protestors or AIPAC away from US elected representatives, though. Gotta feeling that Caspar's ghostly arm would soon knock the vase off the stand and still scream "Antisemitism!".
Last edited by Trebb on Sat Jan 03, 2026 9:38 pm, edited 1 time in total.
He who knows only his side of the case knows little of that.
User avatar
Callafangers
Administrator
Posts: 1134
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2024 6:25 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Callafangers »

Trebb wrote: Sat Jan 03, 2026 9:22 pm So, the only recourse against this conclusion (Jews may well be accountable for collective actions, just like the evil Nazi Brexiteers are) is for Nessie and the dearly deported Confused Jew to say "not all Jews!". Well, yes, great, but it does not get you very far. It is entirely legitimate for nations to want to treat the Jewish state as an independent, foreign state and hence rid itself of things like AIPAC or mitigate the effects of the widespread sayanim. If one wanted to dress this up nicely, one could say, "It aint all Jews, we just reject the Isreali spy and influencer network" - not sure that would keep the UK Police away from elderly female protestors or AIPAC away from US elected representatives, though. Gotta feeling that Caspar's ghostly arm would soon knock the vase off the stand and still scream "Antisemitism!".
Howdy Trebb, welcome to the forum (I see you have a few posts already but this is the first I have come across).

I think your dressed-up version is pretty much the best way to call out the problem in a way that won't guarantee getting 'cancelled'. Well-put. Although it's surely only a matter of time before they add that exact phrasing to the IHRA 'definition of antisemitism'. :roll:
Forensics lack both graves and chambers—only victors' ink stains history's page.
User avatar
Trebb
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2025 12:15 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Trebb »

Hello Callafangers, thank you for the greeting.

Yes, very enjoyable forum. I had read a lot of threads before first posting (I think I was on the old forum too, briefly). Chiefly here to work through Holocaust claims, but lots of interesting threads across other topics have pulled me in (e.g., Charlie Kirk). Great reading and linked sources.

Yes, anti-antisemitism, where generalisations can only work one-way.
He who knows only his side of the case knows little of that.
User avatar
Wahrheitssucher
Posts: 650
Joined: Mon May 19, 2025 2:51 pm

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Wahrheitssucher »

More evidence showing our govts, law-enforcement systems, etc., are CONTROLLED by Jewish collectives:







PLUS Jewish-collectives use our own police and courts to punish resistance to their control:

A ‘holocaust’ believer’s problem is not technical, factual, empirical or archeological — their problem is psychological.
User avatar
Trebb
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2025 12:15 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Trebb »

Yes. Already noticed the Zionist-Venezuala-Trump axis. Real Risk board game being played out now. Edge out Iran and pressure Russia. Trump is even bullish when answering "US boots on the ground in Venezuala" questions. Uniformed Gringos in South America? The US regimes are addicted to their Vietnam-style defeats, it would seem. Let's hope this one is brief, the last was 2 decades long, very expensive and the loss of Afghan, US and Allied lives wholly futile.

This Doctor Rahmeh Aladwan. Yes, I used to like the idea of tolerance, and would be appalled at the partiality of the UK government - surely all views should be heard. But I am getting tired of foreign conflicts being played out across all areas of British life, even in our hospitals. Multiculturalism is not a nice thing; it is the reason we cannot have nice things. I wish these various Middle Eastern partisan factions would all go out to the Middle East and fight it out over there. We are getting very jaded.
He who knows only his side of the case knows little of that.
User avatar
Wahrheitssucher
Posts: 650
Joined: Mon May 19, 2025 2:51 pm

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Wahrheitssucher »

.
Another Freudian slip…

A ‘holocaust’ believer’s problem is not technical, factual, empirical or archeological — their problem is psychological.
User avatar
Trebb
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2025 12:15 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Trebb »

Good grief!
Who was that?
He who knows only his side of the case knows little of that.
User avatar
Callafangers
Administrator
Posts: 1134
Joined: Tue Sep 24, 2024 6:25 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Callafangers »

I have often seen people who attempt to deflect all criticism of Zionism/Israel onto 'Netanyahu's corrupt government', which is ridiculous to anyone who has taken the Jewish/Zionist question seriously. This video below shows how it is not the Israeli state which is to blame but, by and large, it is the Israeli people:



The video engages in the usual "they're even worst than muh 'Holocaust' :( " nonsense (skip ahead to ~3 minutes to avoid much of this), which is especially common on videos which are critical of Israel/Zionism, since presumably the creators (uneducated on revisionism) feel an insecurity or need to prove how 'non-antisemitic' they are, even when the 'Holocaust' is hardly relevant to their topic. In any case, this video is helpful and effective at making the case that the issue is not just 'Netanyahu's government' -- it's "the Jews".

Some key points/highlights:
  • Israel & Gaza: Post-ICJ genocide plausibility ruling (Jan 2024), Israelis engage in "genocide tourism" (school trips, Birthright tours viewing Gaza destruction via binoculars; night boat trips staking land claims amid bombings).
  • Finkelstein Quote: Israeli society's public glee/exultation over Gaza is unmatched, soldiers boast online.
  • Active Participation: Settlers/Israelis block/loot Gaza aid trucks (condemned by White House), aiming to kill/expel Palestinians for annexation.
  • Tel Aviv Univ. Poll: ~60% of Israelis say military uses too little firepower in Gaza; 37% say appropriate; only ~1-2% say too much.
  • Moral Dilemma: Israeli society doesn't just cheer genocide but actively participates, making it "darker evil" than the state.
  • Reagan Story: In 1982, President Reagan called Israeli actions in Lebanon a "holocaust" in a call to Israel's PM, citing child casualties.
Forensics lack both graves and chambers—only victors' ink stains history's page.
User avatar
Trebb
Posts: 13
Joined: Fri Nov 14, 2025 12:15 am

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Trebb »

"WHO IS THE PROBLEM?..." - one Hell of a subtitle on the video's thumbnail! The conclusion pulls the punch "The society is deranged". Not really the correct word for it, "deranged"; it has an aim and it is close to succeeding in it.

Finkelstein, in another video, says the job is nearly done.

92% of the building stock is gone and settlers are taking cruises to drool at the wide array of property stake options. The residents of the concentration camp are dead or injured or starving and I guess a few got to flee. Homes lost, settlements razed, society broken, many dead, all to make way for a different people. That is ethnic cleansing, that is genocide. More than "plausibly genocide", which, I guess, was a UN plea for Israel to stop, to give them room to.

It is total war. I find it hard to believe that Israel will ever have the nerve again to point to the Holocaust. This is the end for that, I suspect.
Callafangers wrote:The video engages in the usual "they're even worst than muh 'Holocaust' :( " nonsense (skip ahead to ~3 minutes to avoid much of this)
It suffused the whole video, to be honest. I just had to watch all of this introduction before completing the whole video. Glad I did. Apparently the National Socialists published pamphlets about the death camps saying they were work camps where Jews and others had a decent enough life, even did sports, and helped with the war effort and learned new trades and such. No evidence of any of that at the end of the war, of course. I wonder how the Nazis thought they would fake survivors? I wonder when the vlogger will give serious thought to the question of whether the German society did give rise to the Holocaust he has in his mind.
Callafangers wrote:Tel Aviv Univ. Poll: ~60% of Israelis say military uses too little firepower in Gaza; 37% say appropriate; only ~1-2% say too much.
1-2%?

So not all Israelis.

They are morally finished. You can either have your total war or you can have your Holocaust moralisation gap - you cannot have both.

It is also becoming quite clear that Israel came quite close to being totally finished by Iran in their recent war. The defence shield was, even at its best, insufficient and could not be plugged by US supply quickly enough toward the end of this, frankly, brief war. Lots of high value targets precisely taken out by Iran. Trump having to step in with that Al Swearengen act, "They've both been fighting too hard for too long, I call an end!". Obviously his intervention was only ever about saving Israel's skin.

Hence more desperate grabs toward stabilisation. Trump's kidnapping of the Venezuelan President to obviate ongoing cooperation with Iran and Russia. Embassy already pledged to be moved to Jerusalem. It feels ever more like World War soon.

The October 7th narrative is being ever more exposed as exaggeration and partly a fabrication. The babies in ovens claim seems to be totally bogus - what does that remind us of?

A couple of years ago I had a lot of sympathy with Israel and with Trump. Now it is obvious that Trump is hugely constrained, and mainly by Israel it seems. The agenda Trump is adhering to is quite clearly an Israel First agenda. It now seems unthinkable that a POTUS ever said what Reagan said to Israel in 1982, but then, perhaps, that's what being an assassination survivor can do to you. So I wonder what Trump's excuse is.

Seems Americans can no more vote their way out of their mess than can we Britons vote our way out of ours.
He who knows only his side of the case knows little of that.
User avatar
Wahrheitssucher
Posts: 650
Joined: Mon May 19, 2025 2:51 pm

Re: Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted

Post by Wahrheitssucher »

.
Here’s a great deal of info showing how Jews are heavily ’involved’ in the illegal President Maduro abduction and non-judicial ’show trial’.



The narrator is wearing a mask presumably to hide her identity in order to avoid repercussions from ’jewish’ collectives.
A ‘holocaust’ believer’s problem is not technical, factual, empirical or archeological — their problem is psychological.
Post Reply