The CODOH Revisionist Forum

.... You cannot settle any sort of serious debate by citing basic fallacies. It will come down to the actual substance of the arguments and evidence. Spamming fallacies is similar in effect to ad hominem attacks. What happens if both sides start doing it? "You're doing fallacies." "No, you're doing ...

What is JP? Hitler wrote Mein Kampf before 1925. It is thoroughly racially antisemitic. This was nearly a decade before Stalin undertook any program against Volga Germans. Jewish Policy. Now what gives you the idea that Mein Kampf is 'racially antisemitic'... It has racialist parts. That is true ...

To prove those witnesses lied, you need evidence from other witnesses, documents drafted at the time, archaeological studies, photos and physical evidence gathered from the relevant locations. You do not have any of that. You do not even know that they even existed. Actual fact is that you would to ...

Furthermore, the mutual assistance agreement was not only valid in case of aggression, it would be valid even if Poland started the war. That is arguably a bit different. Blanket Invasion of Germany by Poles would be a difficult sell. Rather provoke as long as you can get a reaction and the ...

I have read Stolfi's book, and it is an excellent rebuttal to all the biographies he mentioned, in particular Kershaw's which he quotes throughout the book. One book I can recommend is Hitler's National Socialism by Rainer Zitelmann. It provides something close to a fair overview of Hitler's ...

There can be valid reasons to mobilize one's army. But if it is apparent conflict with a neighbor taking a more confrontational course signals a credible threat with war. A credible threat is a justification of self-defense. The Poles will insist that the German occupation of Bohemian and Moravia ...

..... Tik argues that Germany declared war on the British because Hitler knew the consequences, but Hitler was never ready to defeat them. Furthermore, he treats the Polish state as an unblemished country, whose existence would be worth defending at the cost of his own empire, and it does not seem ...

.... The issue of the topic is their alleged right and morality to go to war against Germany. Tik uses arguments such as the mutual assistance agreement with Poland, forgetting the contradiction of only being valid in relation to Germany, this kind of answers the title of the video, and the moral ...

I do not think anyone doubts Jews have some Khazarian admixture. These would be the Ashkenazi Jews. Sephardic Jews located around Spain and Portugal, would most likely to be related to the original Habiru who were semites. Some Polynesians consider themselves Jewish as do Asians. https://images ...

.... Exterminationists have in recent years pretty much given up entirely on the physical evidence debate. I have not seen/heard any significant activity at all from the likes of Muehlenkamp and Hans in this regard (the only ones I recall in the last decade ever focusing on physical evidence ...

TlsMS93 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 18, 2024 9:12 pm ....

It's great to have you here again Hektor, welcome.

Thanks....

More people noticing that the narrative isn't adding up as they may have thought in the past.

There is no evidence of even ten massive shipments of firewood or gasoline to any of the AR camps. Yet, you require some tens of thousands for your exterminationist beliefs to be true. And documentation aside, there would at least be witness statements about such significant happenings in these ...

Does Pohl offer any evidence of this in Nazi decision making? None of the pre-Barbarossa orders are particularly specific and none mention Volga Germans, at least that I can remember. I think the evidence was mostly circumstantial with Policies on Jews occurring after there were policies against ...

.... Hektor, just gotta say it is a pleasure to see you here, sir. This is the old 'Butterfangers'. I have been as 'Callahan' on the RODOH forum in the interim that this one has been down. Hence, 'Callafangers' currently. Welcome back. Thanks for welcoming me back. I had a turbulent time the past ...

If they actually had a case they wouldn't waste their time trying to debunk Revisionists. Yet that's all they do.