Page 3 of 4
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 7:43 am
by bombsaway
Bro the Nazgul is violating one of the forums core rules, provide evidence when you make a claim
Re berg, this has come up before
https://www.codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=501#p501
The Nazgul can't just say, it's in the book, look harder
"No Dodging" If you make a controversial claim without support, others have the right to request support. You must respond in some fashion, either by explaining your basis for the claim (whatever it may be) or by conceding that support is lacking
You guys seeing this? The Nazgul, God bless him, is not budging an inch in his blatant disregard of the forums rules. Impressive really
And Nessie is the one doing this to him
Keens similar claims about posters dodging are not analogous. We have provided a "basis" for the claims in all cases, keen just doesn't view them as sensible or correct and erroneously labels this dodging. If he were correct Archie surely would have intervened by now. Care to comment Archie?
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:51 am
by Nessie
Nazgul wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 7:06 am
Nessie wrote: ↑Sun Sep 21, 2025 10:55 am
I do not believe your claim he was a ramp Kapo in Birkenau. Hence, despite being given the book, you refuse to provide any quotes.
Prove he saw transports arrive inside Birkenau and the subsequent selections.
Your beliefs are of little relevence. The proof is in the book.
Show me. I have linked to the two references he makes to a ramp, and neither involve him working at it. There was also more than one ramp, on in Birkenau and another outside.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 11:29 am
by Nazgul
bombsaway wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 7:43 am
The Nazgul can't just say, it's in the book, look harder
Nessie has not read his memoirs, I have.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 11:37 am
by Nessie
Nazgul wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 11:29 am
bombsaway wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 7:43 am
The Nazgul can't just say, it's in the book, look harder
Nessie has not read his memoirs, I have.
So why are you refusing to link and quote him talking about working as a Kapo on the ramp at Birkenau?
https://archive.org/details/scheisshaus ... g/mode/2up
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 12:17 pm
by Nazgul
That link is meaningless to most. Either way his work, his memoirs speak nothing of the nonsense you sprout. Read it, if you can.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 12:23 pm
by Keen
bombsaway wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 7:43 am
Keens similar claims about posters dodging are not analogous... keen just doesn't view them as sensible or correct and erroneously labels this dodging.
bombsaway,
1 - Is it - True. - or - False. - that; Non-nefarious diggings for such things as garbage pits, cellars, wells, latrines, septic pits, etc. - were dug at Treblinka II - ??
2 - Is it - True. - or - False. - that; Archaeologists can easily distinguish a garbage pit from a mass grave?
3 - How many actual mass graves did CSC actually prove actually exist within the boundary of the Treblinka II camp?
Three simple questions is all it takes to expose the lying, low IQ HC cowards lies.
Now let's sit back and watch bombsaway squirm!
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 2:39 pm
by Nessie
Nazgul wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 12:17 pm
That link is meaningless to most. Either way his work, his memoirs speak nothing of the nonsense you sprout. Read it, if you can.
The link shows you are either lying, or you made a mistake.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 8:25 pm
by bombsaway
The Nazgul is doubling, tripling down. Is he trolling?
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 9:55 pm
by Keen
bombsaway wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 8:25 pm
The Nazgul is doubling, tripling down. Is he trolling?
bombsaway, we're waiting for you over here:
viewtopic.php?p=16186#p16186
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:48 pm
by bombsaway
Look I'm not claiming I have any evidence that will ever convince you or meet your standards. The Nazgul, on the other hand, says there's something in the book but refuses (so far) to show this is the case.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:57 pm
by Nazgul
Nessie wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 2:39 pm
The link shows you are either lying, or you made a mistake.
The link you provided once had the full book available to all members as with the works of Sam Pivnik; the link is limited in scope. You and Bombsaway are aguing against material I have read and you have not. Pierre was non Jewish whereas Sam was. In his memoir Pierre fell for a girl named Stella at a holding camp prior to his transportation to Birkenau, where he describes his fear, his illness, his work on the ramps with a female kapo from the female quarters, his attempts be be an electrician at Monowitz but failed as he was not an electrician. He describes his loss of virginity to another man. Finally after working at Dora and the end of the war, he found two skeletal remains in some hunting lodge. He was asked to become a policeman in some small village before returning to France where he vomited violently after eating good food. I will obtain the book from the library along with Pivniks book and find the relevant information.
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2025 12:04 am
by bombsaway
Nazgul wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:57 pm
Nessie wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 2:39 pm
The link shows you are either lying, or you made a mistake.
The link you provided once had the full book available to all members as with the works of Sam Pivnik; the link is limited in scope. You and Bombsaway are aguing against material I have read and you have not. Pierre was non Jewish whereas Sam was. In his memoir Pierre fell for a girl named Stella at a holding camp prior to his transportation to Birkenau, where he describes his fear, his illness, his work on the ramps with a female kapo from the female quarters, his attempts be be an electrician at Monowitz but failed as he was not an electrician. He describes his loss of virginity to another man. Finally after working at Dora and the end of the war, he found two skeletal remains in some hunting lodge. He was asked to become a policeman in some small village before returning to France where he vomited violently after eating good food. I will obtain the book from the library along with Pivniks book and find the relevant information.
What was the memoir called, that has this description?
What is Pivnik's book?
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2025 12:14 am
by Keen
bombsaway wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:48 pm
Look I'm not claiming I have any evidence that will ever convince you or meet your standards.
bombsaway, I edited the question so you can use your own standard of proof to answer.
viewtopic.php?p=16186#p16186
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2025 6:21 am
by Nessie
Nazgul wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 10:57 pm
Nessie wrote: ↑Mon Sep 22, 2025 2:39 pm
The link shows you are either lying, or you made a mistake.
The link you provided once had the full book available to all members as with the works of Sam Pivnik; the link is limited in scope. You and Bombsaway are aguing against material I have read and you have not. Pierre was non Jewish whereas Sam was. In his memoir Pierre fell for a girl named Stella at a holding camp prior to his transportation to Birkenau, where he describes his fear, his illness, his work on the ramps with a female kapo from the female quarters, his attempts be be an electrician at Monowitz but failed as he was not an electrician. He describes his loss of virginity to another man. Finally after working at Dora and the end of the war, he found two skeletal remains in some hunting lodge. He was asked to become a policeman in some small village before returning to France where he vomited violently after eating good food. I will obtain the book from the library along with Pivniks book and find the relevant information.
You made a claim you cannot evidence, that is against forum rules.
""No Dodging" If you make a controversial claim without support, others have the right to request support. You must respond in some fashion, either by explaining your basis for the claim (whatever it may be) or by conceding that support is lacking. All posters need not agree on whether the support provided is convincing, but outright refusal to respond will be considered "dodging." Citing overly vague support (like a lengthy source with no explanation) may also be considered non-responsive."
Re: Treblinka/Malkinia and the Missing Witness Statements
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2025 7:06 am
by Nazgul
Nessie wrote: ↑Tue Sep 23, 2025 6:21 am
You made a claim you cannot evidence, that is against forum rules.
I am not making a claim, I am mentioning the memoirs of a ramp Kapo at Birkenau who never mentioned the nonsense often spouted by you and others. As you have not read the book, lack comprehension skills if you tried, you should not comment. Most of the information asked for was written in the last RODOH. Memory is evidence whether you like it or not. You willingly accept the failed memories of Jews think others lack the same capacity, telling very telling. As Mr Bergs memoirs are related to only Birkenau, Dora and his search for Stella, they are off topic for this thread which is on Treblinka and Malkinia. While he thought he would be murdered and believed in the atrocities he never saw any first hand.