BA's thoughts on resettlement

[Keen]

They were killed, all the non working ones at least.

Oh, so some were killed and some were resettled huh?

Interesting.

bombsaway, If you can show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up - deal?

Oh, and I mean with proof - got it?

[bombsaway]

They were killed, all the non working ones at least.

Oh, so some were killed and some were resettled huh?

Interesting.

bombsaway, If you can show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up - deal?

Oh, and I mean with proof - got it?

No I don't think resettlement happened at all, at least not permanently. Jews were ghettoized, which might count as resettlement, but this was a temporary thing. The ghettos were closed down or massively reduced in size and converted to work camps.

[Keen]

They were killed, all the non working ones at least.

Oh, so some were killed and some were resettled huh?

Interesting.

bombsaway, If you can show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up - deal?

Oh, and I mean with proof - got it?

No I don't think resettlement happened at all, at least not permanently. Jews were ghettoized, which might count as resettlement, but this was a temporary thing. The ghettos were closed down or massively reduced in size and converted to work camps.

So bombsaway admits that jews were sent to Treblinka II and were not killed and he admits that he can't show me were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up.

So what he's admitting is that there is more evidence suporting resettlement than the magically disappearing jew theory.

Sounds like holocaust denial to me!

[Keen]

Do you think the Holocaust case would be stronger or weaker if none of this evidence existed?

I noticed that you didn't say "physical evidence."

Let's say two naked people were standing in one specific place, an area of about one square meter, and person A was killed and buried right there in that specific square meter place and person B was not killed and was allowed to walk away and leave the area.

Which person, A or B, would leave the most physical evidence in that specific place?

Here's a little something that might help you with your answer:

[Keen]

It should be easier to find evidence of survival than a one time execution. We know that when people are alive they continuously are active in the world, perceived by others, need food/lodging, represent security threats, communicate amongst themselves and to others. Even if the expectation is as much evidence generated or less, revisionists have put forward next to nothing, so even this is a fail. In the manner of Callafangers, you must argue that the expectation is many thousands of time less evidence could be expected to be generated, and even here you would expect something to slip through. But it hasn't.

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

What are you waiting for?

What are you so afraid of?

[bombsaway]

It should be easier to find evidence of survival than a one time execution. We know that when people are alive they continuously are active in the world, perceived by others, need food/lodging, represent security threats, communicate amongst themselves and to others. Even if the expectation is as much evidence generated or less, revisionists have put forward next to nothing, so even this is a fail. In the manner of Callafangers, you must argue that the expectation is many thousands of time less evidence could be expected to be generated, and even here you would expect something to slip through. But it hasn't.

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

What are you waiting for?

What are you so afraid of?

This is the resettlement thread, nothing to do with graves.

I'm sure you can show some Jews who were sent to T2, were drafted into the labor force, and sent along to other camps in Poland. What you cannot do is show a single Jew who went through these camps and ended up "resettled" in the USSR.

Here's what I said, "They were killed, all the non working ones at least."

[Keen]

Even in threads about resettlement, the topic is clearly not one that is so interesting to revisionists... This is the resettlement thread... I don't think they were resettled, you made a big mistake here because it's clearly a topic you're not interested in.

I am very interested in the resettlment issue bombsaway.

So interested in fact, I've started a thread about the issue. Maybe you've seen it?????

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=493

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

What are you waiting for?

What are you so afraid of?

[Keen]

bombsaway:

The ratio is reference to your question of how much evidence would be expected to be generated for both events. 1:1 would mean as much evidence generated for mass killing as resettlement.

bombsaway,

Let's say two naked people, person A and person B, were standing in one specific place, an area of about one square meter, and person A was killed and buried right there in that specific square meter place and person B was not killed and was allowed to walk away and leave the area.

Which person, A or B, would leave the most physical evidence in that specific place?

Let me help you here with your answer bombsaway.

Here is an example of the physical evidence that person A would leave behind:



And here is an example of the physical evidence that person B would leave behind:

[Keen]

bombsaway, if you had 2.145 million of these:



you wouldn't even need to bring up the subject of resettlement, would you?

But all you have is this:

[bombsaway]

bombsaway, if you had 2.145 million of these:



you wouldn't even need to bring up the subject of resettlement, would you?

But all you have is this:

This is a thread on resettlement, so I don't want to get into grave stuff here. I will respond elsewhere and we can continue the conversation from there.

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=14740#p14740

[Nessie]

...

This is a thread on resettlement, so I don't want to get into grave stuff here.

Keen has nothing to contribute, evidentially, to the topic of resettlement. He is just like the rest of the so-called revisionists in that respect.

[Keen]

bombsaway, if you had 2.145 million of these:



you wouldn't even need to bring up the subject of resettlement, would you?

But all you have is this:

This is a thread on resettlement, so I don't want to get into grave stuff here. I will respond elsewhere and we can continue the conversation from there.

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=14740#p14740

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

[Keen]

...

This is a thread on resettlement, so I don't want to get into grave stuff here.

Keen has nothing to contribute, evidentially, to the topic of resettlement. He is just like the rest of the so-called revisionists in that respect.

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

[bombsaway]

This is a thread on resettlement, so I don't want to get into grave stuff here. I will respond elsewhere and we can continue the conversation from there.

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=14740#p14740
[/quote]

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.
[/quote]

I responded to you already, and you didn't reply back in that thread. You can go pollute other threads with your talk of graves, Mods Keen is being off topic here. I have no interest in horse trading w you, if you have evidence of resettlement post it. BTW Jews going to T2 and being drafted into the work force and being put to labor in Poland is not resettlement and I can also give you some names here. Not relevant for this thread though.

[Keen]

if you have evidence of resettlement post it.

I do have evidence of resettlement - proof in fact, but first things first:

bombsaway, when you show me exactly were one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently killed ended up, I'll show you where one jew who was sent to Treblinka II and subsequently not killed ended up.

What are you waiting for bombsaway?

What are you so afraid of?