Page 2 of 2

Re: On the question of "corroboration"

Posted: Thu Jun 11, 2026 8:13 pm
by Hektor
TlsMS93 wrote: Sun Jun 07, 2026 11:36 pm Concentration camps are like Universe 25; regardless of whether it was German, these kinds of things will always surface. And since those who operated the camps ended up being defeated, it became easy to establish whatever they wanted to establish. After all, who's going to believe the "Hitlerian gangs" and their common-sense crimes?
The narrative is far to much pushed to be believed at face value, still people do.

Re: On the question of "corroboration"

Posted: Tue Jun 16, 2026 5:35 pm
by pilgrimofdark
Further in Collect and Record!, Laura Jockusch points out that the methodological guides/questionnaires developed by the Central Jewish Historical Commission were also used in the Displaced Persons camps.

Some members of the Polish CZKH joined the Munich Central Historical Commission:
  • Moshe Feigenbaum (briefly worked)
  • Shmuel Glube (briefly worked)
  • Menachem Marek Asz (took Treblinka eyewitness testimony)
  • Betti Ajzenstajn (edited volume of sources on Jewish resistance)
  • Leon Weliczker (published a Janowska/Aktion 1005 memoir that was "developed/prepared" by Rachel Auerbach)
According to Jockusch, the Munich Commission had nine questionnaires, of which three were based on the Polish methodological instructions.

One difference is that the Munich questionnaires were to be filled out by the survivor or commission member. In Poland, they were guidelines for use during interviews.

So instances of "witness coaching" should be less prevalent in the DP accounts than those produced in Poland.

Thousands of the Munich DP camp documents are in Yad Vashem's documents collection under "M.1 - Documentation of the Central Historical Commission (CHC) of the Central Committee of Liberated Jews in the American Occupied Zone, Munich." The questionnaires aren't digitized, but a few testimonies are.

Re: On the question of "corroboration"

Posted: Tue Jun 16, 2026 7:55 pm
by Callafangers
pilgrimofdark wrote: Tue Jun 16, 2026 5:35 pm Further in Collect and Record!, Laura Jockusch points out that the methodological guides/questionnaires developed by the Central Jewish Historical Commission were also used in the Displaced Persons camps.
This is an understated work in revisionism. Glad you're referencing it.