The CODOH Revisionist Forum

The point stands: there is no organic drive for 'survivors' to come out and share their stories. And for Jewish organizations largely coordinating any/all survivor interviews, selective outreach, lines of questioning, editing, or even just limiting historical access by requiring on-site campus ...

Yes I would expect them to remember leaving the ghetto and being sent to a resettlement camp or camps staffed by Germans in Russia, being held there for years until liberation by the Soviets. The proportion of Soviet gulag survivor testimonies we have are miniscule. There are only 16 known ...

If you're Mordechai do you tell your children, your wife, etc, about what happened to you? Do you even know what happened to you? Do you draw out a timeline of the exact months or even years? Were you looking out the window (if any) at the signs (if any) as your train rolled into the next location ...

If you're Mordechai do you tell your children, your wife, etc, about what happened to you?

Also see this thread, in which revisionists sought to analogize what apparently happened in Occupied USSR to other places - a self-own https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=6355#p6355 Every population transfer in recent history has been accompanied by a wealth of documentary and testimonial ...

So call this guy Mordecai Yah, I would just say for this example imagine you are a Polish Jew who was resettled by the Nazis. The camp you were kept in was horrible, with conditions similar to the ghettos or worse. You survived there for years (1942 to 1944) until the Soviets came and liberated the ...

https://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.com/2017/03/evidence-on-babi-yar-massacre-29-30.html Archie, can you go through the Babi Yar documents and tell me your feeling on if they were faked or not? You can speak probabilistically and roughly here. If you accept that they all might be real, I'll show ...

"Odd, ain't it?"

https://chatgpt.com/share/68216a63-f1ec ... 283418b790

It's an important question Stubble. This tells you what you need to know from the orthodox perspective

Oh please. Empress of Pilpul Tactics, spare us the condescension. I've always found it "interesting" to see how the hoaxers weave psychology into their arguments. Whether studying the 'psychological phenomena of Holocaust denialists' or focusing on the 'psychology of evil [Nazis]', or of the ...

The USSR absorbed millions of people in its annexations. Do you really think that adding around 2 million more would make a difference in a country where it is said that 26 million died in the war? Yet those people are (at least in part) accounted for in the witness and documentary record. There is ...

Yah, I would just say for this example imagine you are a Polish Jew who was resettled by the Nazis. The camp you were kept in was horrible, with conditions similar to the ghettos or worse. You survived there for years (1942 to 1944) until the Soviets came and liberated the camp. Instead of going ...

Firstly, consider the "resettled" Jews themselves. Even if one concedes significant Jewish deaths due to wartime conditions, disease, or sporadic violence – events which would, in fact, intensify the desire of any survivors to recount their true experiences – and posits that only a few hundred tho ...

This thread was about fabricated documents.

How many of those Babi Yar documents are fabricated, they're all real you think?

"fabrication of documents," Not very many. There are, what, three explicit gas chamber/gas van documents? I would agree that a large number, say more than a hundred, is not realistic, but I don't think that was the case. Gas van documents I count 5 or 6 here that revisionists say would be fake 4,5 ...

"vast coordination between Soviet and Allied governments" This is your spin (distortion). If there had been vast coordination, the earliest versions of the stories would be more coherent and consistent. They aren't precisely because so much of it was nothing but sloppy war-time atrocity propaganda ...