The CODOH Revisionist Forum

Here's a shot: Comprehensive Framework for Evaluating Historical Documents Total: 100 Points I. Provenance and Discovery (22 points) Criteria for Evaluation: - Discoverer credibility and discovery circumstances (0-6 points) Who discovered the document and under what circumstances? Is the discoverer ...

The 52,000 filmed Holocaust testimonies speaks to a characteristic of Jews to talk about their persecution. Assuming they were kept in resettlement camps, conditions here were no doubt going to be pretty poor so they would have testified about them just like they testified about the ghettos and the ...

Yes I would expect them to remember leaving the ghetto and being sent to a resettlement camp or camps staffed by Germans in Russia, being held there for years until liberation by the Soviets. The proportion of Soviet gulag survivor testimonies we have are miniscule. There are only 16 known ...

If you're Mordechai do you tell your children, your wife, etc, about what happened to you? Do you even know what happened to you? Do you draw out a timeline of the exact months or even years? Were you looking out the window (if any) at the signs (if any) as your train rolled into the next location ...

To ignore the jewish interest in the holocaust narrative as we have come to know it would be naive. To ignore the zionist interest in it would be stupid. To ignore allied complicity (the 'noble lie') is short sighted, in my opinion. Not everyone involved with the hidden hand wears a small hat, and ...

Ya so how do you know that those "reunions" are actual reunions and not just false positives? You don't. But if you would expect there to be a lot of false positive, that means the reported number of reunions, which isn't even that many, is over reported. You're an assclown. People do not fly out ...

Some exterminationists have implied or expressed their view that it would be unlikely for Jews to coordinate dishonestly at any scale to advance a common narrative which ultimately benefits their tribal network. The claim is, therefore, that we should not put much weight to observed patterns of ...

Also see this thread, in which revisionists sought to analogize what apparently happened in Occupied USSR to other places - a self-own https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=6355#p6355 Every population transfer in recent history has been accompanied by a wealth of documentary and testimonial ...

Ya you don't understand the argument that you are making. If there are going to be many false positives, you'd expect to find way more false cases of reunited survivors and you simply don't see even a fraction of as many as you'd expect if the Holocaust was fake. Like not even within the same solar ...

...I think Himmler was referring there to the actual killing of partisans and their families. .... https://holocausthistory.site/1942-12-29-meldung-nr-51-himmlers-report-to-hitler-on-the-execution-of-363211-jews-in-just-four-months/ "On December 29, 1942, Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler delivered ...

The fact that there was supposedly a population bottleneck within the Ashkenazi gene pool is kind of irrelevant but it would make it easier, not harder to locate missing relatives. I missed this earlier. If you're talking about finding closer relatives (which is generally the case for our ...

While I agree with everything else written in this post, I must disagree with this part. I think Himmler was referring there to the actual killing of partisans and their families. In recognition of Archie's "individual documents as part of a larger whole", consider this third speech which repeats ...

A small percent of DNA reunions are expected. Unless you make a statistically sound argument, copying even 50 articles, won't prove anything. I think it is you who needs to first validate your expectation for any particular number threshold of reunions. You have made no such attempt. Is 51 ...

I completely understand the arguments that I'm making but you honestly don't seem to understand yours so let me break this down for you very simply. There is no use in you making assertions about your intentions. You have completely shot your credibility, as shown here: https://www.codohforum.com ...

It's one thing to be cautious about editorial bias, especially in postwar Eastern Bloc publications, but bias in how something is published doesn’t equal forgery. The Auschwitz Sonderkommando manuscripts were discovered buried near the crematoria starting in 1945, and their authenticity has been c ...