The CODOH Revisionist Forum

Nothing to do with Gerstein. The 20 vs 28 depends on what you assume for the total death tally. Both densities are very high. 600,000/21,310 = 28.2 434,508/21,310 = 20.4 Gerstein claimed the graves were absolutely enormous. If such graves as Gerstein describes existed, the bodies would fit easily ...

Archie, what do you mean by bluffing or pretending? I'm a true believer. I would bet my life on the Holocaust having happened, within some reasonable range -- millions dead, mass gassings I have no doubt whatsoever that Nessie is a true believer. And I think you most likely are as well. But the ...

Like I said, I'm being generous. If someone can show me any grave anywhere that has achieved anywhere close to 28 bodies per cubic meter I will reconsider my position. Based on the data I have, I rate the Holocaust story wildly implausible, and I feel good enough about that to conclude that it ...

This letter is dated Nov 22, 1944 and it says it is a reply to a letter from McClelland from Nov 17. This was only a bit before the Morgenthau's WRB distributed the "Auschwitz protocols" to the press. I do not see McClelland's original letter in the file, but from the response it is clear that he ...

Transports were far less frequent by late September 1944, and if the ICRC is correct that Rossel visited on 27 September 1944, there hadn't been a transport since September 20; the next transports arrived on September 29. This could be a valid point, but it's very thin on evidence. We are usually ...

Wikipedia is OBVIOUSLY NOT a credible source for anything concerning controversial or contested topics related to jews. Grow up. Wiki like any other web based encyclopedia gets linked because it's convenient and it also cites at least some sources. …Forum discussions are going to be a mishmash of s ...

Wikipedia is OBVIOUSLY NOT a credible source for anything concerning controversial or contested topics related to jews. Grow up. Wiki like any other web based encyclopedia gets linked because it's convenient and it also cites at least some sources. You seem to have overlooked how my posts ...

Archie wrote: ↑Sat Jun 28, 2025 6:39 pm

HansHill wrote: ↑Fri Jun 27, 2025 6:24 pm Nessie is so roundly checkmated its embarrassing to see him continue arguing.

You know it's bad when SanityCheck has to jump in with one of his proof-by-word-count posts to try to save it.

Nessie can fend for himself, I replied to *you*.

The December 1942 publicity stirred up an inconvenient public response in the UK, so the various organs of the British state including the Political Warfare Executive (dictating to the BBC as well as the governments-in-exile) backpedalled on further prominence for such reporting, suppressing or ...

You are welcome to argue this, but if this debate makes its way into the public square and these are the arguments I have to say I like our chances. Most people will see the problem immediately and no amount of spin doctoring about they were able to guesstimate six million in 1944 is going to save ...

I said murdered, every jew that died in ww2 was murdered by a nazi? No jew died of injury, no jew died of age, no jew died of natural causes what so ever? None of the other megacide and genocide death tolls make such distinctions so people don't with the Holocaust. Hairsplitting and trying to make ...

Mr Check, did 6,000,000 jews die at the hands of nazis in an act of murder, specifically murder, during the second world war? No, something just over five million Jews died This is so f*cking stupid and you're basically making Revisionists point for us. I'm not telling you what country I am in ...

Mr Check, did 6,000,000 jews die at the hands of nazis in an act of murder, specifically murder, during the second world war? No, something just over five million Jews died at Nazi *and Axis* hands (primarily the Romanians and Croatians). Hilberg's 5.1 million is good enough for working purposes ...

With any rounded number figures there are - ironically - at least six approaches which can be taken: 1) outright deniers 2) doubters and minimisers 3) avoiders 4) fudgers ('millions', 'hundreds of thousands' depending on scale) 5) recalculators and those quoting them (for the Holocaust, the ...

And the 50 odd years before ww2 they knew it was going to be 6,000,000 because, they had a 1 in 10 chance, got it... No offense, your reasoning is absurd given the history of the number as a claim and the fact that it is incongruent with the reality of 'the holocaust (tm)' whatever it actually was ...