>Material evidence
>Muh eyewitnesses

Nessie in a nutshell, ladies and gentlemen.
You have no evidence they arrived. Remember all those train stops
I have just proved that you fail at the basic task of any investigation, criminal or historical. You cannot evidence what happened. In particular, you cannot evidence TII had an alternative use and the hundreds of thousands who are evidenced to have arrived at the camp, mostly left.HansHill wrote: ↑Thu Mar 13, 2025 5:40 pmNessie in a nutshell, ladies and gentlemen.
He has opted into believing the testimony of liars and exaggerators rather than use critical thinking skills and observing the actual material evidence - but not only that, he in turn demands that only other people telling him that the liars are liars will suffice as evidence.
It is the so called revisionist charade that falls apart. Historical revisionism is normally a change from one version of events to another, which revisionists cannot do. Instead, they deny the historical version and just leave it at that, with no conclusion. Those deniers are the ones who do not really know the details, as their knowledge of the evidence, evidencing and logic is poor.I'm so glad this charade is falling apart. Most people only believe it because they don't really know the details. No wonder people are starting to disbelieve in record numbers as soon as they hear the details and apply critical thinking! Nessie on the other hand, no such luck!
That is merely your incredulous opinion, which has no evidential value.Stubble wrote: ↑Thu Mar 13, 2025 6:13 pm Even if you took the supposed victims and turned them into a liquid and poured it into the maximum proposed grave space, they still would not fit...
You cannot shove 800,000 pounds into a 5 pound bag. It won't fit.
Being generous to the orthodoxy, there is at most space for between 120,000 and 170,000 bodies in the grave space. If crammed in sardine style.
With no top fill, 220,000 ish.
You are lying. There is evidence from Jewish, Nazi and Polish witnesses of packed trains arriving at TII and Nazi reports of transports to and arrivals at the camp.
For which you have no evidence people got off.Remember all those train stops
In 1945 the Poles reported an area of 2 hectares, up to 7m deep, that contained buried cremated remains. Your "only" description ignores that even 1.6 hectares is an area larger than any mass grave site in history. No plague or other mass death has resulted in a site that large. It is the equivalent to nearly 5 football fields.PrudentRegret wrote: ↑Fri Mar 14, 2025 4:40 am Caroline Coll's GPR results are such an own goal. Courtesy of Blake from SSF- the covered-up areas of Treblinka are only about 1.6 hectares. Given that Colls found no significant mass graves of a corresponding size or shape to those alleged outside the covered areas, they rely on an absurd hope that 100% of the covered area covers the real mass graves. But the actual possible areas those mass graves could be theoretically is no more than 2 hectares for the burial of 700,000-800,000 people, with 1.6 hectares of that being covered areas which most certainly is not all grave space.
The memorial was placed where grave robbers had been most active and the ground most disturbed. As for rigorous scientific study, revisionism does not provide that. Instead, overconfident, uneducated assertions are made that there is insufficient space. Those biased opinions have zero evidential value.AFAIK the memorial stones weren't even placed in those areas based on any rigorous scientific study. The Treblinka Story is so incredibly weak it's absurd.
There are a number of camps in the area: Treblinka 1, Two Judenlagers, Malkinia transit camp, TII, Kosow lacki. No one is saying people did not arrive. As mentioned the presence of camps implies inmates. There is an assumption that the whole transport arrived at the final destination intact, this is not likely.
They did not disembark at the station but the wagons with the people were separated from the main train. Some wagons were shunted near the sites of rail junctions.For which you have no evidence people got off.
.The camps around Siedlce were closing, often long before TII closed. Their populations were small, leaving the issue of what happened to everyone else? When they closed, the camps sent their prisoners to TII.
Very interesting, maybe they are expanding the memorial.HeiligeSturmV2 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 24, 2025 5:09 pm During the summer of 2024, some group was digging at Treblinka near the monument.
Treb01.jpgTreb02.jpgTreb03.jpg
(I think this is the area where the symbolical cremation pit should be.)
Not sure what they were doing there but no mass graves found.
And what evidence of mass murder / burial of 925,000 jews did they uncover that that people are "denying"?Nessie wrote: ↑Thu Mar 06, 2025 4:04 pmIt is not going to be done again, to satisfy those who deny the existing archaeological evidence.TlsMS93 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 06, 2025 1:54 pmIt is not allowed because they doubt what is down there, every crime today where there is concealment of corpses is the duty of the authorities to exhume the most likely locations. But we know why they don't do it, Jews, if it were any other people on the face of the earth, it would have already been done and this issue resolved.
Really?
To cravenly refuse to bet that you can prove what you allege has been proven, is a tacit admission that you know what you allege - has not been proven.A $1,000.00 bet - can be made for each one of the 15 fraudulently alleged / insinuated - mass graves / cremation pits - of Treblinka II - wagering that you can conclusively prove that they have been scientifically proven to actually exist and to currently contain the remains of at least 21 people.
To accept - THE $100,000.00 HOLOCAUST ARCHAEOLOGY HOAX CHALLENGE - simply challenge Greg Gerdes (see contact information below) to accept the following - Prove That It Has Been Proven - Wager:
I, _?_, am so confident that the so-called Treblinka II “holocaust within the holocaust” happened as alleged in orthodox historiography, and that the scientific / archaeological / forensic investigations of this site were legitimate, and that the alleged “huge mass grave discoveries” were conclusively validated; that I am willing to bet Greg Gerdes $1,000.00 that I can definitively prove - in a publicized debate and in a U.S. civil court - that there is a preponderance of conclusively documented and substantiated scientific / archaeological / forensic evidence which proves, with 100 % certainty, that Treblinka grave number _?_ currently contains the remains of no less than _?_ people. Furthermore, I agree that if I refuse to answer any question or get caught lying during our debate or while in court - I lose the bet / case right then and there.
Note: You must verify your identity and the grave that you are wagering on must coincide with the answer that you give to question 25 in the following questionnaire (which you must complete and submit along with your challenge) - THE HOLOCAUST ARCHAEOLOGY HOAX - Mass Graves / Buried Remains - Forensic Evaluation Form (AKA):
25 - Of the 15 alleged Treblinka II graves / cremation pits in question - the one that you can conclusively prove currently contains the most human remains is number: _?_.
https://thisisaboutscience.com/