The CODOH Revisionist Forum

Merry Christmas to all in the Revisionist community and Happy Hanukkah to our Exterminationist friends!

Those are the rules of informed evidence based discussion. Otherwise you're a crank or falling for crank tactics. What utter rubbish did I just read? Where to even start with this train wreck I'll begin with your brazen attempt to discard contemporaneous Jewish reports because they make ...

I dunno, in the absence of solid numbers to go on, I think we're going to have to agree to disagree here. I think there are plenty of reasons why Jews in that region of Poland would choose to stay and accept Soviet citizenship. You haven't said anything about the Hryciuk article and the numbers ...

I don’t question that the original Jewish Yearbook said “many.” Both 500,000 and 64,000 could be considered “many.” It’s an imprecise word. The wording is indeed unfortunate*, but thankfully there is also a reason given which speaks to their evident motivation as to why they would wish to avoid defe ...

... And seemingly you've somehow forgotten Orthodoxy's challenge to thread these Jews through the eye of a needle placing them first squarely in German occupied territory, being transported to the East without encountering a transit camp, which by definition would mean certain death (!) Then upon ...

Since I don’t think Jews who accepted Soviet citizenship were deported to the Soviet interior, it doesn’t really pose a problem. My position is that these Jews remained in the Kresy and were therefore still there when the German invasion happened. I understand you are being geniune, so because of th ...

Your claim is that “them” refers to the group that accepted Soviet citizenship. But I think he’s referring to the group that refused citizenship. I believe this for a few reasons: I am genuinely trying here and would appreciate your indulgence. The end point of this line of reasoning is that we see ...

The Polish Jewish population was 3.3 million in 1939. Admitting that had dropped to around half a million by 1945, does not help your cause! There were 9.5 million Jews in Europe in 1939. Admitting that had dropped to c1.4 million, plus the c500,000 in Poland, so c1.9 million, by 1945, does not ...

You can map millions of Jews in Nazi camps in 1944-5? Let me see that, please. We can see massive movements of Jews after you baselessly claim they were gassed, yes. 1945: Per WJC - 475,000 - 525,000 alive and present Polish Jews, incl 80,000 currenlty in Poland 1945: Per WJC - 1,250,000 - 1,500 ...

Are you saying he has no comments on Indian people save for, he wishes for a homogenous Britain to rule India?

Do you have any quote where he calls them subhuman, low IQ, inferior, undesirable?

Utterly amazing!

I find it harder to argue that all these millions were killed, without leaving a trace, while a war of epic proportions was at its peak, where all the already scarce resources were directed to such a war, than to argue that they could have been pushed into occupied Soviet territory, where logically ...

Nessie wrote: ↑Fri Dec 20, 2024 8:17 am
No revisionist thinks through the geopolitical implications of their hoax claim and the extent to which it would benefit so many to expose it.

I was addressing this ridiculous assertion you made. The hoax, and its implications are accounted for.

Ok, I’m beginning to see some of the problem — some confusion on both my part and yours. Here’s you above: 500,000 Jews offered Soviet Citizenship in 1940 following the German / Soviet partition of Poland, with "almost all" being transported to the Soviet interior - source American Jewish Yearbook, ...

Hitler saw Indians as subhuman, that didn't mean the Nazis killed every Indian they saw, it doesn't matter how the nazis saw the race, it matters what they do to 'em What exactly did Adolf Hitler say about Indian people? I've just control+f'd in Mein Kampf and all he talks about India is his ...